Nicely crafted bikes, i'd lean to the cafe racer, but it has a couple of styling issues.
Front mudguard, should be smaller and alloy or black.
The headlight mounts should not be curved and painted, but need to be angled straight section and chromed.
How can you have a cafe racer without clip on handlebars.
I notice in the background of some shots is a Velocette Thruxton, could do a lot worse than take some styling queues from that bike.