speedrattle
Well-Known Member
sikatri, there is one modern oil formulation that has caused problemd in the past and that is the increasing sulfur content in gear oils, which can corrode yellow metals in tbe presence of higher heat and moisture.
the older GL-4 mixes were of intermediate EP levels and *lower* concentrations of sulfur compounds. later GL-5 gear oils had much higher levels of sulfur, and corroded tje copper, brass, and bronze in older gearboxes. so tne general recommendation was to avoid GL-5.
i follow this controversy very casually and tberes lots of disagreement tbese days about whether modern GL-5s will damage old motorcycle boxes. certainly the hypoid-friendly EP additives arent necessary with the ancient straight-cut gears our stuff uses.
i think the answer here is to look at tbe label and make sure the gear oil is safe for yellow metals.
one example where a later grade is not always backwsrds-compatible
the older GL-4 mixes were of intermediate EP levels and *lower* concentrations of sulfur compounds. later GL-5 gear oils had much higher levels of sulfur, and corroded tje copper, brass, and bronze in older gearboxes. so tne general recommendation was to avoid GL-5.
i follow this controversy very casually and tberes lots of disagreement tbese days about whether modern GL-5s will damage old motorcycle boxes. certainly the hypoid-friendly EP additives arent necessary with the ancient straight-cut gears our stuff uses.
i think the answer here is to look at tbe label and make sure the gear oil is safe for yellow metals.
one example where a later grade is not always backwsrds-compatible